TL;DR
Central Bank of Ireland Governor Gabriel Makhlouf argued at a Dublin workshop on Nov. 13 that Europe’s renewed interest in industrial policy reflects weak productivity growth, competitiveness concerns and geopolitical change. He urged policymakers to remain open to targeted intervention but cautious about costs, poor targeting and support that is hard to end.
Central Bank of Ireland Governor Gabriel Makhlouf said Europe’s renewed debate over industrial policy is driven by weak productivity growth, competitiveness concerns and a more fragmented global economy, while warning that targeted state support can be costly and difficult to reverse. Speaking at a Dublin workshop on Nov. 13, he called for policymakers to examine the evidence carefully rather than treat industrial policy as either taboo or a ready-made solution.
Get smart everyday buys delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Makhlouf defined industrial policy as government action aimed at specific firms or sectors to change the composition of economic activity. He said the term applies to services as well as manufacturing. In his account, the subject has moved from the margins of economic debate to a more open discussion, as governments respond to economic and geopolitical pressures.
He pointed to a long slowdown in productivity growth. The figures in his speech show annual labour productivity growth in the United States falling from 2.7% in 1995–2007 to 1.3% in 2007–2019. In larger European economies, it declined from 1.3% to 0.5% over the same periods. Makhlouf also said research and development spending was about 3.5% of GDP in the United States, compared with about 2.2% in Europe.
He linked Europe’s concerns to difficulties scaling up high-productivity businesses and fragmented capital markets that rely heavily on bank lending, which he said can be poorly suited to risky innovation. The speech also cited recent shocks, including the pandemic, the energy and inflation effects following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, higher trade barriers and a renewed rise in global energy prices after the attack on Iran.
Why Europe Is Reconsidering State Support
The debate matters because industrial policy can direct public money and influence which industries, firms and technologies grow. European governments are considering such tools while also facing fiscal constraints. Decisions to subsidize or otherwise support selected sectors can affect public budgets, competition and the allocation of investment across the economy.
Makhlouf’s remarks frame the choice as more than a return to old industrial strategies. Geopolitical tensions and concerns about supply chains have strengthened calls for Europe to build capacity and retain room to make its own decisions. But if support protects established firms rather than enabling new capabilities, it may weaken the competition and investment it is intended to promote. The governor’s central message was that the changed environment warrants serious analysis, not automatic endorsement.
Products Worth Considering

Samsung ViewFinity S7 27-Inch 4K UHD Monitor

Dell 32 Plus 4K Monitor (S3225QS), 31.5-Inch VA, 120Hz, FreeSync Premium

Samsung 27-Inch M5 (M50F) FHD Smart Monitor
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Economic Taboo to Policy Debate
For decades, many economists were skeptical of government efforts to pick sectors for support. Makhlouf recalled the concern that governments lack reliable criteria for choosing industries, may struggle to identify valuable spillovers and can leave policy open to lobbying or capture by special interests. He said the historical record is mixed: some targeted support appears to have built lasting capabilities, while other interventions favored incumbents and proved difficult to unwind.
He argued that views have shifted as productivity concerns, technological change and geopolitics have grown more pressing. The speech cited the Draghi and Letta reports as part of Europe’s renewed focus on competitiveness, and referred to “open strategic autonomy” as a policy aim: maintaining the ability to make choices while preserving openness and fair trade. Makhlouf also pointed to a recent World Bank policy report as an example of changing views on industrial policy.
“To me, it means a policy targeting specific firms or sectors, with the goal of changing the composition of economic activity in the economy through government action rather than leaving it to the market.”
— Gabriel Makhlouf, Governor of the Central Bank of Ireland
Which Interventions Can Work
The remarks do not identify specific industrial-policy measures Makhlouf endorses, nor do they set out criteria for deciding which sectors or firms should receive support. The speech’s opening section calls for careful analysis but does not provide a cost estimate, a proposed funding plan or an assessment of particular European programs.
It also remains uncertain how governments can distinguish support that builds lasting capabilities from measures that shelter incumbent firms or attract political influence. The productivity and research-spending figures describe historical periods cited in the speech; they do not establish that industrial policy would close the gaps. The remarks do not quantify the likely effects of artificial intelligence or future energy-price changes.
Evidence Before New Commitments
The remarks opened a workshop organized by the Centre for Economic Policy Research, University College Dublin and the Central Bank of Ireland, bringing historical and contemporary evidence into the discussion. The next step for policymakers, in Makhlouf’s framing, is to use that evidence to assess whether targeted measures address a clear problem and whether their costs and risks can be managed.
The speech does not announce a new Irish or European policy, a timetable for government action or a specific recommendation for funding. The debate is likely to continue as Europe considers competitiveness, technology investment and strategic autonomy alongside constrained public finances. Whether that discussion produces new interventions—and what conditions or safeguards might accompany them—was not specified in the remarks.
Key Questions
What does Makhlouf mean by industrial policy?
He defines it as government policy targeting particular firms or sectors to change the composition of economic activity. His definition covers services as well as manufacturing.
Why is Europe discussing industrial policy again?
Makhlouf points to slow productivity growth, concerns about competitiveness, difficulty scaling up firms, and geopolitical fragmentation. He also cites technological change, including AI, as part of the debate.
Did Makhlouf announce a new policy?
No. His remarks set out reasons for renewed interest and urged a balanced assessment. They did not announce a specific Irish or European program.
What risks did he identify?
He said targeted support can protect incumbents, direct investment toward politically favored firms and become a large public expense. Such programs can also be difficult to unwind.
What remains undecided?
The speech did not specify which sectors should receive support, how to select recipients, how measures would be funded or what results they might deliver. The effectiveness of any future intervention remains unestablished.
Source: bis.org
